20 October 2010
Cool It--Movie Review
Cool It is a documentary about Danish political scientist Bjørn Lomborg and his views on how the world should, and should not, address climate change.
He insists that the approaches taken so far to mitigate the threat of climate change just haven't worked, are unlikely to work, and cost far too much for the limited benefits they may provide. He says we need a different approach, and has used cost-benefit analysis to prioritize and recommend actions.
For a mere $250 billion a year, he calculates, we could deal with climate change, and eliminate disease and poverty too.
He objects strongly to the scare approach of An Inconvenient Truth (this film is not kind to Al Gore) and says, "We need to scale back the fear."
This may be perceived as dismissing the seriousness of global warming threats. And in fact he does minimize some threats. For instance he repeatedly talks about "one foot" of sea level rise in this century, which he says is about the same as we experienced in the 20th century and we handled that OK. (He likes The Netherlands' local geoengineering approach.) Most observers are projecting higher rises than that.
Lomborg downplays the risk of passing tipping points such as collapse of the Greenland and West Antarctic ice sheets. The film includes interviews with scientists saying how that is just not going to happen. Minimizing the risk of such catastrophic consequences is essential to his argument, since these consequences couldn't be reversed by geoengineering, which is his "insurance policy".
He has made a point of his (possibly revised) belief that global warming "undoubtedly one of the chief concerns facing the world today" and "a challenge humanity must confront". Indeed it was a Guardian article playing up his "apparent U-turn" that has put Lomborg back in the headlines recently (just in time for his film and book promotion tour).
His views do seem to have changed significantly from those put forward in 1998 in Verdens sande tilstand ("The Real State of the World", published later in English as The Skeptical Environmentalist). He would now invest significantly in dealing with global warming, rather than relegating it to much lower priority than fighting disease, poverty and other public policy issues. He now insists that for the amount the EU alone is proposing to spend trying to cut carbon emissions, with little probability of actually affecting warming very much, the world could deal with the climate change problem and other major social problems too if policy approaches were revised.
He recommends investing a lot more in R&D (ten times as much--$100 billion a year) with the expectation that new technology can drive down the cost of alternative energy sources. Those sources will then replace fossil fuels and carbon emissions will be reduced at much less cost than the current heavy subsidization of low-carbon technologies and efforts to impose a price on carbon. He is very enthusiastic about whiz-bang technology and the film features interviews with numerous scientists which interesting ideas, including geoengineering schemes. Geoengineering, to "buy time" and to adapt, is an important element of his technology fix.
He repeatedly says the current approach to dealing with global warming is "broken" and "dumb". He throws a lot of numbers around which may or may not be adequately supported by research and sources. Some of his data is a bit out of date, which is inevitable in this fast-moving field.
I haven't read his books, The Skeptical Environmentalist of 2001, Global Crises, Global Solutions of 2004 (editor), Solutions for the World's Biggest Problems (editor) and Cool It: The Skeptical Environmentalist's Guide to Global Warming both of 2007, nor of course his latest book that is expected to be published in November of this year, Smart Solutions to Climate Change, Comparing Costs and Benefits. But I have heard him speak, and his message seems to still be pretty much in line with what is in the film. (The film is due to be released in the U.S. on 12th November 2010. It has been shown at the Toronto Film Festival and in teaser screenings around the country.)
Cool It starts out as a bit of a hagiography, which may be inevitable in films of this sort (An Inconvenient Truth has a lot of crusading Al Gore in it, after all.) Lomborg is shown to love his mother, to respect nature, to feed impoverished Kenyan kids, and to ride a bicycle. But eventually it gets into the argument and becomes more interesting.
The interviews with scientists supporting to some of his points are inevitably selective. But overall the film gives a good look at Lomborg's views and recommendations, which are not as loony or extreme as some of his detractors might suggest. He may be imprecise, even selective, about many points of climate science, but his basic argument that we are throwing a lot of money at the problem in ways that are unlikely to actually mitigate its effect has some weight.
Lomborg is a political scientist interested in the economics of action to deal with social problems like malnutrition, disease and poverty, not a climate scientist. His welfare economics approach is actually pretty far from the traditional environmentalist/green main stream. To some extent he is speaking a different language. But his arguments do add to the overall debate on what to do about climate change, when to do it, how to pay for it, and whether it is worth doing at all.
The film probably won't win any Academy Awards, but anyone concerned with climate change, who can watch it with something of an open mind, may find it interesting.
Photo by Emil Jupin from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Bj%C3%B8rn_Lomborg_1.jpg
Lomborg is adjunct professor at the Copenhagen Business School, and director of the Copenhagen Consensus Center.
The film was Produced by Ralph Winter (a producer of the X-Men movies), among others, and co-written and directed by Ondi Timoner. Lomborg receives a "written by" credit.
A trailer for Cool It is here. The movie's official website is here.
15 October 2010
Green Business Blog Carnival #19
Another selection of the best of the green business blogs! They guess your weight and tell your fortune in carnival midway style.
(Check Ecolocalizer to see last week's show if you missed it. The sidebar to the right has links to past Carnivals.)
Thanks to all who submitted their favorite posts for this week's Carnival!
Green Business Bloggers take note! You can submit items for future editions of the Green Business Blog Carnival here. Why not publicize your blog, share your insights, and get some links and traffic? Test your strength!
See the schedule for upcoming hosts of the Carnival. If you would like to host an upcoming edition on your very own blog, tha page also tells you how to volunteer. Thanks to Jeff McIntire-Strasburg at Sustainablog and the team at Triple Pundit for keeping this Carnival on the road.
(Check Ecolocalizer to see last week's show if you missed it. The sidebar to the right has links to past Carnivals.)
The Greatest Posts on Earth
- Jaime Nack of Three Squares Inc. posts A Small Green Business Take on Prop 23 at TriplePundit. As a small business owner she sees how "Proposition 23 would undermine the laws that support the rapidly expanding green technology and business sector." Follow TriplePundit's ongoing series about California’s Proposition 23.
- Dan Yurman posts about Spain's erratic energy policy at Idaho Samizdat: Nuke Notes. Once the darling of Europe for solar energy, the country now dithers over future choices without the capital to execute its plans.
- Green Prophet notes Israeli Companies Make "Global Cleantech 100" Guardian List in a post by Karin Kloosterman. "It’s no secret that Israeli cleantech companies and their products are hot commodities. Now in: the Cleantech Group just announced their global list, the Global Cleantech 100 for the second year running, and it’s no surprise that Israeli companies earned 8 of the 100 spots. Five of the companies are listed as being based in Israel; two of them, though founded by Israelis are based in the United States." Karen has interviewed and written feature stories on all of them, except CellEra.
- At CalFinder Jeanne posts a Quiz: 7 Signs Your Company is a Treehugger (Or Greenwashing Machine!) Is your office on the track to sustainability or is it a green mirage? A simple test to determine which direction your company is headed and how you can change the attitude around the water cooler.
- Marta Iglesias posts on the CleanTechies blog: LG Electronics Unveils Plans to Enter US Solar Market. Korean giant "LG plans to capitalize on its existing footprint outside of the US, but it will have to battle hard with well-established American players like First Solar, a thin film leader in the US, or Sunpower, a US leader in monocrystalline, as well as big Chinese competitors such as Suntech or Trina Solar".
- At Eco-Libris Raz Godelnik considers Saving trees or softer touch for the butt? It seems that this is the question consumers have to ask themselves if they're considering using toilet paper made of 100% recycled paper. "Right now, according to NRDC, just 10% of the paper products for home contain recycled content." [This Carnival post is almost entirely recycled content!--Ed.]
- Editor's Choice--Doris de Guzman has a good post about Stonyfield Farm's adoption of bioplastic packaging at the ICIS Green Chemicals blog: Stonyfield yogurt cups from PLA. In addition to her writeup there is video from Stonyfield and a link to its life cycle analysis of PLA cups vs. polystyrene ones. Doris consistently has interesting information in a blog well worth following. Polymers are in everybody's supply chain.
- Here at Doc's Green Blog we analyzed Google's investments and projects in cleantech and green. What have they been up to? Where are they going? See if you can spot trends in the 26 items listed. Are they becoming more focused? "A company this creative, and with this much money, will keep trying new things."
Thanks to all who submitted their favorite posts for this week's Carnival!
The Traveling Carnival
Green Business Bloggers take note! You can submit items for future editions of the Green Business Blog Carnival here. Why not publicize your blog, share your insights, and get some links and traffic? Test your strength!
See the schedule for upcoming hosts of the Carnival. If you would like to host an upcoming edition on your very own blog, tha page also tells you how to volunteer. Thanks to Jeff McIntire-Strasburg at Sustainablog and the team at Triple Pundit for keeping this Carnival on the road.
14 October 2010
What Is Google Doing In Cleantech?
Google Inc. has invested a lot in cleantech and green ventures. Is there any pattern? Here is a summary of Google's investments and projects to date, and thoughts about where it is going.
Google has several "arms" where cleantech activities reside.
The company also has a lot of internal energy-efficiency and emission-offset activities, and other green stuff like bike-sharing and goats as lawnmowers.
At a recent event Bill Weihl, head of Google's renewable energy team, admitted that the RE<C initiative hasn't found as many attractive investment opportunities lately. "It's a little bit bleak," Reuters quotes him as saying. "There aren't that many people working on home runs" to cheap energy, he continued, adding, "We have not seen things that we felt were big enough potential breakthrough and low enough risk."
Greentech Media asked "Has Google’s Green Strategy Begun to Make Sense?" It concludes that the investments have been "a mixed bag" and in some cases "downright wacky", but notes that now it "wants to apply its core competence -- artificial intelligence -- in the realm of efficiency". "Overall, the navigation system fits in much better with Google's strengths than VC investing or solar thermal. Presumably, you can expect more of this sort of thing."
I find it interesting that Google was the sponsor of the "Transportation" category in the California region of the Cleantech Open competition this year. Back in 2007 they sponsored the "Green Building" category.
There is an apparent shift from pure venture investing and spaghetti-to-wall projects toward three areas of emphasis:
A company this creative, and with this much money, will keep trying new things.
[Update 2011 11 23: RE<C project closed]
The Arms of Google
Google has several "arms" where cleantech activities reside.
- Google Ventures--the venture capital arm
- Google Initiatives--the firm's corporate clean energy and sustainability efforts
- Google.org--technology-driven philanthropy, grants and investments
What Google Has Been Up To
| Project or Investment | Date | Arm | Comments |
| Makani Power | 2006-10-11 | Google.org | $10 million series A funding for company developing Airborne Wind Turbines |
| on-site solar | 2006-10-16 | Google Initiatives | 1.6 megawatt solar power system on Mountain View campus buildings from EI Solutions (now Suntech Power) |
| RechargeIT.org | 2007-06-18 | Google.org | "effort within Google.org that aims to reduce CO2 emissions, cut oil use, and stabilize the electrical grid by accelerating the adoption of plug-in electric vehicles"; includes a demonstration fleet of plug-ins at corporate headquarters in Mountain View. |
| plug-in hybrids | 2007-06-18 | Google.org | worked with Hymotion/A123Systems to create fleet of plug-in hybrids for research |
| Innovate or Die Pedal-Powered Machine Challenge | 2007-09-24 | Google.org | collaborated with Specialized and Goodby Silverstein & Partners on YouTube video contest on harnessing pedal power in innovative ways, with prizes of $5,000 in cash and Specialized Globe bikes |
| RE<C | 2007-11-27 | Google.org | "joint Google.org+Google.com climate team created RE<C"; "RE<C will work to develop one gigawatt of renewable energy capacity – enough to power a city the size of San Francisco – at a price cheaper than coal in years, not decades. As part of this effort, Google.org is making strategic investments and grants, advancing key public policies, and using Google products to unlock critical information." Includes EGS project and investments. [Update 2011 11 23: program terminated. See last item this official Google blog post.] |
| Clean Energy 2030 | 2008-01-10 | Google's Proposal for reducing U.S. dependence on fossil fuels. Text here. | |
| eSolar | 2008-01-17 | Google.org | $10 million invested in utility-scale concentrating solar power; also participated in later round |
| BrightSource Energy | 2008-05-14 | Google.org | $10 million equity investment as part of RE<C initiative |
| ActaCell | 2008-07-23 | Google.org | lithium ion battery start-up; investment through RechargeIT program; $2.75 million between ActaCell and Aptera. |
| Aptera Motors | 2008-07-23 | Google.org | electric vehicle start-up; investment through RechargeIT program; $2.75 million between ActaCell and Aptera. |
| Enhanced Geothermal Systems | 2008-08-19 | Google.org | an effort to advance EGS through R&D, investment, policy and information. Investments in Potter Drilling, AltaRock Energy, Inc., Southern Methodist University Geothermal Lab and Stanford University |
| Potter Drilling | 2008-08-19 | Google.org | $4 million investment to develop breakthrough hard rock drilling technologies for EGS |
| AltaRoc Energy, Inc. | 2008-08-19 | Google.org | $6.25 million investment to develop EGS technologies and projects |
| Southern Methodist University Geothermal Lab | 2008-08-19 | Google.org | $489,521 grant to improve geothermal resource assessment techniques and update the Geothermal Map of North America; recent update here |
| Stanford University | Google.org | $135,000 award to research advanced well concepts (part of EGS) | |
| Silver Spring Networks | 2009-03-31 | Google Ventures | Smart grid technology company |
| V-Vehicle Company | 2009-08-03 | Google Ventures | Energy-efficient vehicle company |
| Google PowerMeter | 2009-10-05 | Google.org | free home energy monitor software; collaborating with energy monitor hardware partners and utilities |
| Google Earth Engine | 2009-10-12 | Google.org | computational platform for global-scale analysis of satellite imagery to monitor changes in key environmental indicators like forest coverage |
| mirror technology | 2010-02-26 | developed prototype new mirror technology for concentrating solar power applications | |
| NextEra Energy Resources investment | 2010-05-03 | Google Initiatives | $38.8 million direct investment in a two NextEra Energy Resources wind farms that generate 169.5 megawatts of power in North Dakota |
| NextEra Energy Resources PPA | 2010-07-20 | Google Initiatives | bulk power purchase of clean energy from 114 megawatts of wind generation at the NextEra Energy Resources Story County II facility in Iowa; 20-year PPA and also buying RECs in bulk |
| Shweeb | 2010-09-24 | Google Initiatives | as part of its Project 10^100 Google awarded $1 million to this human-powered transit project |
| self-driving cars | 2010-10-09 | Google Initiatives | Google hired leading developers and has built and tested cars that can drive themselves, logging 140,000 miles so far |
| Atlantic Wind Connection | 2010-10-11 | Google Initiatives (?) | Google to provide 37.5% of the equity for initial development stage of project to build offshore high-capacity transmission line off Eastern Seaboard |
The company also has a lot of internal energy-efficiency and emission-offset activities, and other green stuff like bike-sharing and goats as lawnmowers.
Where are they going?
At a recent event Bill Weihl, head of Google's renewable energy team, admitted that the RE<C initiative hasn't found as many attractive investment opportunities lately. "It's a little bit bleak," Reuters quotes him as saying. "There aren't that many people working on home runs" to cheap energy, he continued, adding, "We have not seen things that we felt were big enough potential breakthrough and low enough risk."
Greentech Media asked "Has Google’s Green Strategy Begun to Make Sense?" It concludes that the investments have been "a mixed bag" and in some cases "downright wacky", but notes that now it "wants to apply its core competence -- artificial intelligence -- in the realm of efficiency". "Overall, the navigation system fits in much better with Google's strengths than VC investing or solar thermal. Presumably, you can expect more of this sort of thing."
I find it interesting that Google was the sponsor of the "Transportation" category in the California region of the Cleantech Open competition this year. Back in 2007 they sponsored the "Green Building" category.
There is an apparent shift from pure venture investing and spaghetti-to-wall projects toward three areas of emphasis:
- Energy efficiency in computing, which is crucial to Google's bottom line,
- Acquiring supplies of clean energy, which will also reduce the carbon footprint of its data centers, and
- Application of its core decision-making tools and web resources to clean technology, as in its Google Earth projects, PowerMeter and self-driving vehicles.
A company this creative, and with this much money, will keep trying new things.
[Update 2011 11 23: RE<C project closed]
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

